Main Navigation Bar (Top of Page)

Pet
Farm/Livestock
Wild Bird & Wildlife
Lawn & Garden
Home/Hardware
Support
Savings/Events

3rd Generation Company

Founded in 1968 Founded in 1968

Pet
- Dog
  
  Dog Food
  
  Dog Treats
  
  Dog Vitamins & Supplements
  
  Dog Chews
  
  Dog Supplies
  
  Dog Toys
  
  Wearables
  
  All Puppy
  
  All Dog
- Cat
  
  Cat Food
  
  Cat Furniture
  
  All Cat
- Small Animal
  
  All Small Animal
- Insect Control & Repellents
  
  Insect Control & Repellents
Farm/Livestock
Wild Bird & Wildlife
- Wild Bird
- Wildlife Feed & Blocks
Lawn & Garden
Home/Hardware
Support
- EGO Service
  
  EGO Service
- Employment
  
  Join Our Team!
- Online Ordering
  
  Delivery
  
  Easy AutoShip
- Contact
  
  Store Locations & Hours
  
  Donation Request
  
  Email Us!
  
  Tax Exempt Application
- Curbside Ordering
  
  How to Order
- Returns & Guarantees
  
  Customer Support Policies
Savings/Events

Login

Login

Pet
- Dog
  
  Dog Food
  
  Dog Treats
  
  Dog Vitamins & Supplements
  
  Dog Chews
  
  Dog Supplies
  
  Dog Toys
  
  Wearables
  
  All Puppy
  
  All Dog
- Cat
  
  Cat Food
  
  Cat Furniture
  
  All Cat
- Small Animal
  
  All Small Animal
- Insect Control & Repellents
  
  Insect Control & Repellents
Farm/Livestock
Wild Bird & Wildlife
- Wild Bird
- Wildlife Feed & Blocks
Lawn & Garden
Home/Hardware
Support
- EGO Service
  
  EGO Service
- Employment
  
  Join Our Team!
- Online Ordering
  
  Delivery
  
  Easy AutoShip
- Contact
  
  Store Locations & Hours
  
  Donation Request
  
  Email Us!
  
  Tax Exempt Application
- Curbside Ordering
  
  How to Order
- Returns & Guarantees
  
  Customer Support Policies
Savings/Events

Filters

Store Availability

Colchester Mackey's (March 2024 Chick Pickup *ONLY*)
Colchester Mackey's
Willimantic Mackey's
Woodstock Mackey's (March 2024 Chick Pickup *ONLY*)
Woodstock Mackey's

Flavor - Peanut Butter Remove filter

Brand

Breed Size

Large Breed
Medium Breed
Small Breed

Category

Bird
Buckeye
Cat Food
Cat Treats
Chews
Dog Food
Dog Treats
Farm Feed
Small Animal
Small Animal Food

Chew Size

Jumbo
Large
Medium
Small
STIX
XSmall

Chew Time

Digestible
Long-Lasting
Non-Digestible

Flavor

Food Type

Food Topper
Raw Dog Treats
Wet Cat Food
Wet Dog Food

Life Stage

Adult
All
Kitten
Puppy

Special Diet

Gluten Free
Grain Free
Healthy Digestion
Rawhide Free
Sensitive Skin
Vegetarian
Weight Management

Specialty

Dental Health

Subcategory

Bird
Catnip
Chincilla
Freeze-Dried
Guinea Pig
Horse
Mouse/Rat
Poultry
Rabbit
Toys
Training
Treats

Home Pet Treats Peanut Butter

Pet Treats

Flavor - Peanut Butter Remove filter

Sort by

Show
24
36
48

View as

Product Image Link

Fromm Crunchy O's Peanut Butter Jammers Flavor Dog Treats

Fromm Crunchy O's Peanut Butter Jammers Flavor Dog Treats

from $5.99

It’s a bird... it’s a plane... it’s Fromm’s very own Nutzo the Great! Blasting through the air and showing the world Peanut Butter Jammers! They’re...

View full details

Product Image Link

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Soft and Chewy Creamy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 6oz

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Soft and Chewy Creamy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 6oz

Wag More Bark Less Original Soft & Chewy Treats have a mouth-watering flavor and soft texture without the nasty preservatives found in other so...

View full details

Product Image Link

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 6oz

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 6oz

Made with natural peanut butter, these soft chews are perfect for all dogs. Free of corn and soy Highly palatable & easy to chew Perfect for o...

View full details

Product Image Link

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Grain Free Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 5oz

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Grain Free Soft and Chewy Peanut Butter Dog Treats, 5oz

Made with natural peanut butter, these soft chews are the perfect treat. Grain free, no added gluten Free of corn and soy Highly palatable & e...

View full details

Product Image Link

Old Mother Hubbard Crunchy Classic Natural P-Nuttier Small Biscuits Dog Treats

Old Mother Hubbard Crunchy Classic Natural P-Nuttier Small Biscuits Dog Treats

$6.99

Our classic P-Nuttier® bone-shaped biscuits are oven-baked with a taste of Peanut Butter and Molasses. Ingredients Whole Wheat Flour, Oatmeal, Whea...

View full details

Product Image Link

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Oven Baked Peanut Butter Crunchy Dog Treats

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Oven Baked Peanut Butter Crunchy Dog Treats

4 simple ingredients including natural peanut butter Free of corn, yeast, sugar, salt, and soy Simple, healthy and tasty ingredients Fun ginger-ki...

View full details

Product Image Link

Redbarn Peanut Butter Filled Hooves Dog Treats

Redbarn Peanut Butter Filled Hooves Dog Treats

$3.99

Natural cow hooves are cleaned, trimmed and stuffed with a peanutty filling to produce a treat that is irresistible and highly palatable! * Mad...

View full details

Product Image Link

Greenies Pill Pockets Canine Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Greenies Pill Pockets Canine Peanut Butter Dog Treats

$9.98

Pill Pockets Treats for Dogs make it easy to give your dog medicine, with a tasty real peanut butter flavor they’re sure to love. Mask the smell ...

View full details

Product Image Link

Benebone Wishbone

Benebone Wishbone

from $10.99

The Benebone Wishbone is our flagship. Since dogs don’t have thumbs, why give them a chew that you can pick up and they can’t? With real bacon, pe...

View full details

Previous
1
2

You recently viewed

Clear recently viewed

Sort by

Main menu

About Us
Shop By Department
Current Sales & Features
Friends of Mackey's Club
Easy Autoship
Delivery
Curbside Call Ahead
EGO Warranty Claim Inspection
Locations
Returns & Guarantees

Subscribe

Join our mailing list for all the latest updates!

Email address

Follow us

Find us on Facebook

Search
Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2024 Mackey's.

Added to your cart:

Product Details Title

Subtotal

View cart () Checkout